Orthorexia: When Eating Well Becomes an Illness - Eden Center

Orthorexia: When Eating Well Becomes an Illness


Variety, balance, and moderation. These are the essential hallmarks of a healthy diet. Food is intended to be an enjoyable aspect of life while providing the nourishment required to keep a body functioning well. Unfortunately, due to factors such as social media, the diet industry, and our country’s unwavering commitment to thinness, how and why people consume foods has altered radically in recent decades.

Although not yet included in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), orthorexia Nervosa is on the increase, as is the number of people seeking treatment for it.

Orthorexia entered the public consciousness in 1997 through Stephen Bratman, a medical doctor. He identified a paradox in many of those who were profoundly committed to healthy eating. Although their stated intention was to promote positive health, their restrictive, obsessive behaviors achieved the exact opposite effect.

A woman with this disorder is consumed by the necessity to eat only “good” foods and cut all “bad” foods from her diet. This black and white approach to food is referred to as dichotomous thinking and is unhealthy. Food should never be given positive or negative labels.

As with most eating disorders, the initial steps are well-intended and start quite innocently. It can start with any “health” food guideline combined with a little bit of science. In no time at all, it evolves into a strategy defined by rigid, unhealthy rules and a very short list of acceptable foods. Popular buzz words such as “clean” and “pure” determine what appears on her daily menu.

This fixation with doing what is right is often exacerbated by a passion for the environment. Acceptable foods are those that leave the smallest carbon footprint.

Initially, this may appear healthful, but it is not. The human body requires everything from vitamins and minerals to protein, carbohydrates, and healthy fats to maintain homeostasis. Obviating entire food groups can lead to malnutrition, illness, even death.

Another component of orthorexia is equally troubling. Those with this disease engage in extensive fact-based research and are therefore very knowledgeable about food, agriculture, and nutrition. This need to know everything ultimately proves deleterious. An orthorexic spends hours researching products, planning meals, searching for stores that carry clean food, then standing endlessly in grocery aisles analyzing ingredient labels. Such pursuits inevitably take time away from work, hobbies, recreation, and importantly, family and friends.

Social isolation often becomes the norm.

The very idea of having to attend a family function or social engagement at a restaurant where food has not been vetted can trigger a full-fledged anxiety attack. Frequently, the only solution is to bring food to the event, which can be socially awkward and offensive to others.

A woman with orthorexia is very strict, controlling, and self-righteous—she knows her belief system and behaviors are just and correct; therefore, and by default, everyone else in the world is wrong.

A woman can live in the shadow of orthorexia for a long time. However, when this disordered eating starts to compromise her body, destroys relationships, or infringes on work, treatment is encouraged. With the right clinical team, a woman can restore her health and develop a positive relationship with food.

Information provided by Chelsea Clarke, MS, RDN, LD

Insurances Accepted

We Work with Your Insurance

Click to Verify Your Insurance